New Insights Report from Lifeway Research helps churches connect evangelism and discipleship
By Aaron Earls
Are the people outside of the church more open to the Gospel than the people inside are willing to share it?
In 2025, Lifeway Research surveyed more than 2,000 U.S. adults who are atheist, agnostic or have no stated religious preference, providing a clearer, data-informed picture of the church’s largest mission field today.
“The secularization trend in America saw a growing percentage of Americans cease to identify with a religion,” said Scott McConnell, executive director of Lifeway Research. “We desired to understand the thinking of these ‘nones’ on many aspects of life and religion.”
At the same time, a Lifeway Research study of more than 1,000 U.S. Protestant pastors identified the reality that churches are growing, but not through evangelism.
“More people are attending worship services because people in the congregation attend more often. But while attendance is rising, the portion of attendees who are new converts or previously unchurched has declined,” McConnell said.
Additionally, Lifeway Research’s State of Discipleship study of more than 2,000 U.S. Protestant churchgoers revealed Christians say they want to share their faith, but their involvement is weak. Among eight discipleship signposts, the average churchgoer scores lowest on sharing Christ.
“Measurement of Jesus’ Great Commission reveals much lower levels of churchgoer involvement than we would expect from His last command,” McConnell said.
Lifeway Research’s Evangelism Today Insights Report digs deeper into the data from these three studies to explore key stats and practical takeaways for pastors and church leaders, highlighting a mission field ripe for harvest, common evangelistic shortcomings and the role of small groups in evangelism.
The mission field
Around a quarter of Americans don’t identify with any religion, but many still hold some religious perspectives.

Slightly more than a third of nones (36 percent) say they have a complete absence of religious beliefs. A similar share (37 percent) say they are somewhere between belief and unbelief, while 12 percent have strong religious beliefs.
Still, few religiously unaffiliated (23 percent) see religion as important in their lives or describe themselves as a person of faith (29 percent). Almost half (47 percent), however, consider themselves spiritual.
As far as their specific religious beliefs, the religiously unaffiliated have a variety of perspectives on God. Almost a quarter (23 percent) aren’t sure if God exists. One in 5 (20 percent) say they believe God does not exist. Fewer say they believe in God and seek to know God relationally (18 percent), believe there is a God but don’t think God can be known (15 percent) or believe there are multiple gods or deities (11 percent). Around 1 in 8 (12 percent) say none of these.
Most (55 percent) believe the existence of supernatural entities is very likely, including 25 percent who strongly agree.
“The nones’ beliefs that the supernatural exists and that there is something deeper, fuller and transcendent defy the secular narrative that people are fleeing all that is religious and spiritual,” McConnell said.
Numerical growth without gospel growth
Amid this cultural landscape, slightly more than half of U.S. Protestant pastors (54 percent) report the average worship service attendance at their church has increased by at least 4 percent since 2023.
Another 30 percent say their congregation has plateaued, staying within plus or minus 4 percent in the past two years, while 16 percent report an attendance decline of at least 4 percent. The average pastor reported 16 percent growth from 2023 to 2025.
Pastors estimate most of their new attendees over the past two years have come from other churches. In the average church, only 20 percent of those new to that church are people who didn’t previously attend church at all.

Around 1 in 6 (16 percent) say half or more of their new attendees are completely new to church, while 12 percent of pastors say none of those who started attending their church in the past two years didn’t previously go to church.
The share of new attendees who are completely new to church has decreased over the past decade. In 2016, the average pastor said 27 percent of their new attendees didn’t go to church before, compared to 20 percent today.
When evaluating new commitments to Christ per 100 attendees, churches have become less effective than a decade ago. In 2016, the average church saw 16 commitments per 100 worship service attendees. By 2025, that number fell to 11 commitments per 100 attendees.
Willing but not intentional
While churchgoers may be praying about ways to tell others about Jesus, many aren’t doing much to make that happen.
More than a quarter of Protestant churchgoers (27 percent) say they have not shared their faith story with someone in the past six months.
For many Christians, this lack of sharing comes from a lack of preparation. Only half of Christians say they’re ready to share at least the basics of becoming a Christian. This includes around a quarter (23 percent) who say they’re ready for any opportunity to tell someone how to become a Christian, and 27 percent are prepared to share the basic steps. Another 1 in 5 (19 percent) say they know the essentials but aren’t comfortable yet putting them into words. A quarter of Christians (24 percent) say they aren’t sure what information needs to be shared or where to start.
Churchgoers may be hindered from sharing their faith with someone because they aren’t building relationships that enable evangelistic opportunities.
Fewer than half (48 percent) say they intentionally spend time building friendships with non-Christians for the purpose of sharing Christ with them, with just 17 percent strongly agreeing. Similarly, 45 percent say they have developed significant relationships with people outside their church for the purpose of evangelism, including 18 percent who strongly agree.
Small group discipleship as the engine for outreach
Analysis of the research points to one practical way churches can close the gap between evangelistic intent and practice: small groups. Churchgoers who regularly attend a small group Bible study, such as Sunday School, have the highest discipleship scores, including in the area of sharing Christ.
Those who participate in small groups at least five times each month have the highest scores of sharing Christ – 69.7 on Lifeway Research’s discipleship scale, compared to an average of 54.8 among all churchgoers. In the past six months, this highly engaged group has shared with someone how to become a Christian 11.1 times on average and invited an unchurched person to a church service or program 7.6 times on average.
By contrast, churchgoers who never attend a small group have the lowest scores on the sharing Christ signpost (41.1) – the lowest score of any attendance group across the signposts. They are also far less intentional about developing relationships that lead to gospel conversations. Compared to those in groups five or more times a month, half as many of those not in groups spend time building relationships with non-Christians for the purpose of sharing Christ with them (30 percent v. 66 percent).
To explore the complete findings, download the free Evangelism Today Insights Report from Lifeway Research.
Earls is a writer for LifeWay Christian Resources.